New Home Star vs Contractor Scale

New Home Star or Contractor Scale: which one actually fits your business?

A straight comparison for builders weighing their options. We'll name where New Home Star is the better choice, where Contractor Scale fits better, and how to tell which one matches your situation.

By Cameron Upton, founder of Contractor Scale

See the Growth System Book a Growth Audit

New Home Star is usually better when...

•You have a new-home sales operation, communities, or a larger sales team.
•You want demand generation connected to sales staffing or sales enablement.
•You sell in a production or semi-production environment.

Contractor Scale is usually better when...

•You are a custom builder where the owner or small team still carries sales responsibility.
•You need pipeline stages, qualification, and feasibility built around high-ticket custom work.
•You want marketing assets and sales infrastructure you own.

Where New Home Star can make sense.

New Home Star's Star Marketing offer is built for new-home builders, communities, and sales organisations. They combine demand generation, HubSpot, SEO, PPC, social, syndication, display, signage, grand openings, retargeting, form strategy, email, realtor/referral programs, incentives, marketing plans, and performance reporting.

Where Contractor Scale is intentionally different.

Contractor Scale is not positioned as a channel vendor. The work is demand, response, nurture, qualification, feasibility, sales process, and attribution wired together so the builder can inspect the full path from first enquiry to signed work.

The question to ask before choosing.

New Home Star is more naturally compared around production builders, communities, sales centres, realtor programs, and new-home sales operations. Contractor Scale is built for premium custom builders and remodelers that need a leaner owned lead-to-sale system.

Side-by-side

The practical difference

Best-fit buyer

New Home StarNew Home Star: You have a new-home sales operation, communities, or a larger sales team.

Contractor ScaleYou are a custom builder where the owner or small team still carries sales responsibility.

Primary priority

New Home StarNew Home Star: You want demand generation connected to sales staffing or sales enablement.

Contractor ScaleYou need pipeline stages, qualification, and feasibility built around high-ticket custom work.

Commercial objective

New Home StarNew Home Star: You sell in a production or semi-production environment.

Contractor ScaleYou want marketing assets and sales infrastructure you own.

Decision lens

New Home StarNew Home Star: New Home Star's Star Marketing offer is built for new-home builders, communities, and sales organisations.

Contractor ScaleNew Home Star is more naturally compared around production builders, communities, sales centres, realtor programs, and new-home sales opera…

Questions worth asking before you choose

Is Contractor Scale a direct replacement for New Home Star?

Not always. If you only need a specific channel improved, a traditional agency may fit. If the bigger issue is the full path from enquiry to contract, Contractor Scale is the more direct comparison.

Why does Contractor Scale compare around systems instead of services?

Because builders often lose margin and momentum after the lead arrives. The system view includes demand, response, nurture, qualification, feasibility, and conversion.

Who is Contractor Scale best suited to?

Owner-led custom builders, design-build firms, and premium remodelers who want better project fit and a more inspectable pipeline.

Client proof

Builder case studies behind the comparison

If you are comparing providers, pressure-test with real outcomes — not promises. These case studies show how demand, response, qualification, and conversion perform in live builder markets.

Email from JRA confirming all properties in the development are under contract

JRA Construction · Auckland

Auckland townhouse project: demand that matched a multi-unit sell-down

JRA needed buyers for a tight eight-unit programme — not tyre-kickers. Four Meta lead-generation angles (General, Young Pros, Investors, Growing Families) produced 287 form leads at about $4,424 spend. When every property in the development was under contract, the client asked to pull the ads.

Units — all under contract: 8
Lead form results: 287
Total Meta spend: $4,424
Blended cost per lead: ~$15.41

Read case study

Davies Building — Contractor Scale build markets (Australia)

Davies Building · Brisbane

Brisbane remodels: search intent into two solid contracts — not quote fodder

Google Ads reached homeowners already looking to remodel in Brisbane. Two solid projects advanced from that demand. Poor-fit enquiries were ruled out fast rather than chased.

Projects contracted: 2 major remodels
Combined project value: ~$1.2M
Primary channel: Google Ads

Read case study

Ambient — Sustainable Living — Contractor Scale build markets (Australia)

Ambient — Sustainable Living · Perth

Perth: new brand for high-performance homes, then demand at a low single-digit CPL

Ambient builds high-performance, low-energy custom homes in a niche where buyers evaluate hard before they contact anyone. The work started with positioning and a site that matched that scrutiny, then layered paid demand on top. Early CPL landed around $5 AUD.

Cost per lead (early window): ~$5 AUD
Deliverables: Brand, site, paid demand
Niche: High-performance / low-energy custom homes

Read case study

Browse all case studies →

Want a straight answer on which path fits?

The growth audit maps where your pipeline is leaking now, what to fix first, and whether Contractor Scale is the right fit for your market.

Book a Growth Audit More comparisons

Related comparisons

Builder Funnel

vs Contractor Scale

Home Builder Marketers

vs Contractor Scale

Bokka Group

vs Contractor Scale